City Halts Electric Bus Program After Second Packed Transport Bursts Into Flames
In every bureaucratic state of a left-leaning flavor, whether it be at a national or regional level, there’s invariably an incredible rush to electrify public vehicle fleets.
In the United States, the Post Office has ordered over 10,000 electric delivery vehicles as part of its fleet replacement program. In the United Kingdom, the government gave a $246 million boost (£200 million) to reach a target of 4,000 electric buses in the country and, according to a March 2022 announcement on a government website, “comes as consultation launched on ending sale of all new non-zero emission buses from 2025 to 2032.”
(Here at The Western Journal, we’ve pointed out what the mainstream media won’t: EVs don’t make the grade in any of these departments, no matter what they say. We’ll continue to bring America these inconvenient truths — and you can help us by subscribing.)
Mind you, electric vehicles have come a long way from the days of the GM EV1 and other earlier experiments in carbon-free transportation. However, the concerns around fleet electrification don’t just involve the rapidity with which governments are pursuing programs which don’t make environmental, economic or practical sense.
Instead, it’s that a rushed electrification program can have serious consequences if the vehicles aren’t ready for the rigors of the roles they’re expected to perform. In Paris, France, public transport officials found that out the hard way.
According to France 24, dozens of electric buses from state-owned public transportation operator Régie Autonome des Transports Parisiens have been taken out of service due to two of them spontaneously exploding on the road in just one month.
On April 4, a Bollore Bluebus 5SE electric bus caught fire on an upscale Paris street — Boulevard Saint-Germain. That didn’t get much attention, however.
This did:
An Electric Bus Caught Fire After Battery Explosion in Paris
Fire consumed an electric RATP bus on April 29 in Paris. No injuries.
The explosion occured on the roof of the bus, where the batteries are located, followed by huge flames that spread quickly to the entire bus. pic.twitter.com/y4jFwCxaCY
— Janet Evelyn ✝️???? (@JEM_Books) May 1, 2022
[firefly_poll]
#Update: Just in – Video of the Fire of the electric driven bus in #Paris today. #France pic.twitter.com/FXYQnBF7qw
— Sotiri Dimpinoudis (@sotiridi) April 29, 2022
That’s one large battery fire. In fact, it took roughly 30 firefighters to put it out.
“The bus driver immediately evacuated all the passengers. Nobody was hurt,” RATP said.
However, 149 buses were immediately taken out of service — which makes sense, considering there were two huge fires in a month.
The fire exposed another issue with greening our government fleets: Contracts often go to companies run by connected folks, which don’t necessarily produce fantastic products.
“Bluebus is part of the sprawling empire of French billionaire Vincent Bollore, whose interests range from transport and logistics to media, generating around 24 billion euros ($25 billion) per year in revenue with 80,000 employees,” France 24 reported.
“Bollore’s 12-metre (39-foot) electric buses are a familiar sight on the streets of the French capital, emblazoned with the words ‘100 percent electric vehicle.'”
And it was definitely emblazoning, let me tell you.
In all seriousness, this is part of the electrification quandary. At the point where two public transit buses catch fire in rather spectacular fashion because the manufacturer says it has battery problems, one wonders why the manufacturer was granted the contract in the first place. Electric vehicle startups are to 2022 what tech startups were to 1999.
The difference is, when Pets.com failed and the online diaper-delivery startups were deservedly consigned to the dustbin of corporate history, nothing blew up. The same can’t be said for the Bollore Bluebus 5SE electric buses.
Perhaps Bollore will work out the kinks quickly and all will be well. However, after viral videos of one of these EV buses burning like a crashed plane, I doubt there will be many Parisians eager to hop aboard again.
This article appeared originally on The Western Journal.
UPDATE, July 29, 2022: Online insurance broker AutoInsuranceEZ.com researched auto fires by type of car using data from the National Transportation Safety Board, Bureau of Transportation Statistics and Recalls.gov and concluded “that despite the focus on EV fires in the news, they are not inherently more dangerous than gas or hybrid vehicles, although electric fires tend to be more difficult than gas fires to extinguish.”
Perhaps more importantly, the independent, nonprofit Insurance Institute for Highway Safety and Highway Loss Data Institute in a study of “electric and conventional versions of nine models from 2011 to 2019” concluded that electric vehicles may be considered significantly safer than similar conventional models because “rates of injury claims related to the drivers and passengers of electric vehicles were more than 40 percent lower than for identical conventional models over 2011-19. This result is similar to an earlier HLDI study of hybrid vehicles, and one likely explanation is that the large batteries used in both types of vehicles make them substantially heavier than their conventional counterparts. Occupants of heavier vehicles are exposed to lower forces in multivehicle crashes.”
The Western Journal is adding this information to this story as important context regarding the safety of electric vehicles in general.
